A complete list of 11 players who played for both Arsenal and Everton, including Arteta, Walcott, Iwobi, and Campbell, with full stats and career highlights.
The footballing highway linking North London and Merseyside is paved with pure drama. When evaluating the history of transfers between Arsenal and Everton, we uncover tales of visionary captains, big-money flops, and remarkable career resurrections.
Here is the complete list of every man who has braved the pressure and played for Arsenal and Everton.
1. Mikel Arteta
-
Everton: 2004-2011 (Apps: 186 | Goals: 31 | Assist: 36), Arsenal: 2011-2015 (Apps: 137 | Goals: 15 | Assist: 7)
Mikel Arteta is undeniably the ultimate symbol among Arsenal and Everton players. The Spanish midfielder arrived at Goodison Park and instantly became the creative heartbeat of David Moyes’ team. His sublime passing range and tactical intelligence made him an absolute fan favourite on Merseyside.
In a dramatic deadline-day move in 2011, Arteta switched blue for red. At the Emirates, he evolved into a deeper-lying playmaker and an exemplary club captain.
Today, the footballing philosophy he forged across both clubs has propelled him to the managerial hot seat, guiding the Gunners as one of the brightest tactical minds in Europe.
2. Kevin Campbell
-
Arsenal: 1991-1994 (Apps: 101 | Goals: 23 | Assist: 12), Everton: 1998-2004 (Apps: 145 | Goals: 45 | Assist: 16)
A powerhouse forward who played for Arsenal and Everton with immense distinction. Rising through the youth ranks at Highbury, Kevin Campbell played a pivotal role in securing the 1990/91 First Division title.
However, his legend status was truly cemented at Everton. Arriving on loan in 1999 while the club was staring down the barrel of relegation, Campbell single-handedly saved the Toffees by bagging nine goals in eight games. He went on to make history as Everton’s first-ever Black captain.
3. Theo Walcott
-
Arsenal: 2006-2017 (Apps: 355 | Goals: 93 | Assist: 56), Everton: 2017-2020 (Apps: 85 | Goals: 11 | Assist: 9)
Bursting onto the scene as a rapid teenage prodigy, Theo Walcott dedicated the prime years of his career to Arsenal. His blistering pace terrorised Premier League defences for over a decade.
Seeking regular first-team action, he became one of the most high-profile transfers between Arsenal and Everton in early 2018. While he never quite replicated his explosive peak at Goodison Park, Walcott’s vast Premier League experience provided crucial stability for the Toffees.
4. Alex Iwobi
-
Arsenal: 2014-2018 (Apps: 150 | Goals: 15 | Assist: 22), Everton: 2019-2023 (Apps: 140 | Goals: 9 | Assist: 15)
A proud product of Arsenal’s Hale End academy, Alex Iwobi flashed moments of absolute brilliance in an Arsenal shirt but ultimately struggled to cement a guaranteed starting spot. Driven strictly by an intense desire to play regular first-team football, the Nigerian international made the difficult decision to leave his boyhood club for Goodison Park in 2019.
After a rocky start, Iwobi completely reinvented himself. Transitioning from a rotational flair winger into a tireless, undroppable midfield engine, he became an indispensable figure in Everton’s brutal relegation dogfights.
5. Martin Keown
-
Everton: 1992 (Apps: 13 | Goals: 0 | Assist: 0), Arsenal: 1992-2003 (Apps: 347 | Goals: 7 | Assist: 7)
Football fans immortalise Martin Keown as the ultimate Arsenal warrior – a terrifying centre-back who anchored the legendary “Invincibles” squad at Highbury.
Many forget that Keown actually enjoyed a brief stint at Goodison Park in the early 90s. He showcased his trademark aggression in his 13 appearances for the Toffees, using the Merseyside club as the final stepping stone before cementing his monumental Arsenal legacy.
6. Francis Jeffers
-
Everton: 1997-2003 (Apps: 67 | Goals: 18 | Assist: 12), Arsenal: 2001-2002 (Apps: 29 | Goals: 4 | Assist: 1)
The classic tale of a wonderkid crushed by expectations. “Franny” Jeffers exploded onto the scene at Everton as a lethal poacher. Convinced he had found his ultimate “Fox in the Box”, Arsene Wenger paid £8 million for the young striker in 2001.
Tragically, brutal injuries and immense pressure destroyed his confidence. He managed just four league goals for the Gunners before being loaned back to Goodison Park, marking one of the most notorious transfers between Arsenal and Everton in history.
7. Anders Limpar
-
Arsenal: 1991-1993 (Apps: 36 | Goals: 3 | Assist: 4), Everton: 1993-1996 (Apps: 66 | Goals: 5 | Assist: 11)
Anders Limpar brought pure, unadulterated flair to English football. The exceptionally gifted Swedish winger was a driving force behind Arsenal’s 1990/91 title-winning campaign.
Moving to Everton in 1994, Limpar continued to sprinkle his magic. He played an instrumental role in Everton’s stunning 1995 FA Cup final victory over Manchester United, cementing his status as a cult hero for both sets of supporters.
8. Shkodran Mustafi
-
Everton: 2009 (Apps: 1 | Goals: 0 | Assist: 0), Arsenal: 2016-2020 (Apps: 151 | Goals: 9 | Assist: 4)
A bizarre piece of trivia: the World Cup-winning German defender actually started his senior career at Goodison Park. Mustafi was handed a single substitute appearance in the Europa League by David Moyes in 2009.
Years later, he arrived at the Emirates for a massive £35 million fee. Despite securing two FA Cups, Mustafi’s Arsenal tenure was heavily defined by high-profile defensive blunders.
9. Stephen Hughes
-
Arsenal: 1994-1999 (Apps: 54 | Goals: 5 | Assist: 4), Everton: 1999-2000 (Apps: 29 | Goals: 1 | Assist: 3)
A dependable midfield prospect from Arsenal’s youth system, Stephen Hughes stepped up with crucial goals during the Gunners’ glorious 1997/98 double-winning season.
Unable to secure a permanent spot, he transferred to Everton in early 2000, playing a solid but brief single season before moving down the football pyramid.
10. Philippe Senderos
-
Arsenal: 2004-2007 (Apps: 82 | Goals: 4 | Assist: 0), Everton: 2009 – Loan (Apps: 3 | Goals: 0 | Assist: 0)
The Swiss centre-back had patches of brilliant form at Arsenal, notably helping the team set a Champions League clean-sheet record. Looking to rebuild his shattered confidence after a tough spell at the Emirates, Senderos joined Everton on a short loan in early 2010 but managed only three appearances.
11. Richard Wright
-
Arsenal: 2001 (Apps: 16 | Goals: 0 | Assist: 0), Everton: 2002-2006 (Apps: 60 | Goals: 0 | Assist: 1)
Signed by Arsenal with the heavy burden of replacing David Seaman, Richard Wright’s brief time in London was a rollercoaster of great saves and costly errors. After just 16 games, he bailed out and headed to Everton.
Wright actually put together a very solid 2002/03 campaign at Goodison Park before a freak knee injury cost him his starting job.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Who is the most successful of all the Arsenal and Everton players? Mikel Arteta. He was the tactical focal point for Everton, the captain of Arsenal, and has now evolved into an elite Premier League manager at the Emirates.
2. Why was Francis Jeffers considered a flop? Arsenal spent big money on Jeffers expecting him to be a prolific goalscorer. Unfortunately, severe injuries and the immense pressure of competing against Arsenal’s legendary forwards completely derailed his development.
3. How many men have played for Arsenal and Everton in the Premier League era? Excluding the women’s teams, exactly 11 male players have represented both clubs.
4. How much did Everton pay Arsenal for Alex Iwobi? In one of the most expensive transfers between Arsenal and Everton, the Toffees secured Alex Iwobi on deadline day in 2019 for an initial fee of £28 million.
You have just read the article “Arteta, Flops & Heroes: 11 Arsenal and Everton Players”. Follow 52Hz Football for more captivating stories about football, geography and culture.
READ MORE:
-
- Arsenal and Bayer Leverkusen Players: A Statistical Look at 4 Shared Stars
- All Players Who Played for Real Madrid and Man City
- The London-Paris Connection: All Players Who Played for Chelsea and PSG
- All Players Who Played for Real Madrid and Man City
- Liverpool vs Galatasaray: 12 Players Who Represented Both Clubs
