We have all heard the term “one-season wonder“.
Football is full of players who lit up a league for a single campaign before completely losing their form. But to be honest, surviving at the top level for nine whole months is still a massive achievement.
Therefore, we decided to dig much deeper to find something truly bizarre and incredibly rare: the “One-Match Wonder“.
These are the forgotten players who spent all the luck, magic, and elite essence of their entire careers within exactly 90 minutes. They touched the absolute pinnacle of world football for just one single game, only to permanently sink back into the shadows of obscurity immediately after.
Here is the countdown of the 10 most insane and iconic “One-Match Wonder” cases.
10. Altay Bayindir
-
Match: Manchester United vs Arsenal (FA Cup, January 2025).
At Manchester United, Altay Bayindir had been warming the bench under the massive shadow of Andre Onana. However, in the FA Cup third round at the Emirates, the Turkish shot-stopper made the whole world say his name. He played brilliantly for 120 minutes, saved Martin Odegaard’s penalty in extra time, and then pushed away Kai Havertz’s shootout effort to directly eliminate Arsenal. The media instantly hailed him as the Red Devils’ “penalty-saving god”.
Many fans thought his golden era had finally arrived when Onana left the club at the dawn of the 2025/26 season. Unfortunately, he crumbled under the pressure. A string of poor, unconvincing performances quickly shattered the illusion, forcing Manchester United to hastily enter the transfer market and sign Senne Lammens to replace him.
Looking back, that miraculous night at the Emirates was truly just an isolated “One-Match Wonder” moment in an otherwise underwhelming Old Trafford career.
9. Michele Di Gregorio
-
Match: Real Madrid vs Juventus (FIFA Club World Cup, July 2025).
Facing Real Madrid is always a nightmare for any goalkeeper, but Michele Di Gregorio turned the newly expanded FIFA Club World Cup into his own stage.
During this massive global tournament in the summer of 2025, the Juventus keeper delivered an insane performance with 10 spectacular saves, continuously frustrating world-class attacking superstars like Kylian Mbappé and Vinícius Júnior.
For those 90 minutes, Di Gregorio looked like the best goalkeeper in the world. However, that aura disappeared as fast as it arrived.
Returning to Serie A for the 2025/26 season, his form plummeted disastrously. A series of silly and comical mistakes turned his great Club World Cup night into an isolated, baffling “One-Match Wonder” phenomenon.
8. Reece Oxford
-
Match: Arsenal vs West Ham United (Premier League, August 2015).
A 16-year-old starting on the opening weekend of the Premier League is already a shock, but playing like a midfield boss is an earthquake. Reece Oxford had an unbelievable debut, completely neutralizing Mesut Özil, Santi Cazorla, and Aaron Ramsey to help West Ham secure a stunning 2-0 win right at the Emirates.
The English media immediately went crazy, labeling him the “next Rio Ferdinand”, and expecting him to captain the Three Lions in the future. Unfortunately, the massive media pressure suffocated the young talent.
After that performance of a lifetime, Oxford’s form slid. He was constantly loaned out, and eventually drifted to Germany, never fulfilling the promise of those glorious 90 minutes.
7. Axel Tuanzebe
-
Match: Paris Saint-Germain vs Manchester United (Champions League, 2020).
The Parc des Princes in 2020 witnessed one of the greatest modern defensive performances by Manchester United. Axel Tuanzebe – a young center-back constantly battling injuries – was handed a start against the most expensive duo on the planet: Kylian Mbappé and Neymar.
While Aaron Wan-Bissaka was putting on his own trademark slide-tackling masterclass on the right flank that night, it was Tuanzebe in the center who truly shocked the world. Surprisingly, he played the game of his life, matching Wan-Bissaka’s intensity to completely “pocket” the French side’s attack.
That night, Red Devils fans believed they had found their rock for the new decade. Cruelly, persistent injuries denied Tuanzebe. He quickly lost his form, was ousted from Old Trafford, and slowly faded into an inexplicable “One-Match Wonder”.
6. Juliano Belletti
-
Match: Barcelona vs Arsenal (Champions League Final, 2006).
Juliano Belletti was a hard-working full-back, but he was never considered a dangerous attacking threat. Stats show that during his 3 years with the Catalan giants, Belletti played over 70 games and didn’t score a single goal.
Except for… one. In the 2006 Champions League final, as Barcelona struggled against Arsenal, Belletti came from the bench. In the 81st minute, he surged forward and hit a decisive strike through the legs of Manuel Almunia, bringing the prestigious European cup to Barca.
One single goal, but enough to carve his name into the club’s hall of fame forever.
5. Tony Watt
-
Match: Celtic vs Barcelona (Champions League, 2012).
In 2012, Pep Guardiola’s Barcelona was an invincible destroying machine at the peak of tiki-taka. Celtic winning 2-1 against such a great team was already a fairy tale, but the hero who scored the winning goal shocked the world even more: Tony Watt, an 18-year-old kid.
His acceleration and cold-blooded finish to beat Victor Valdes made Celtic Park erupt. Watt’s name appeared on the front pages of every global sports newspaper.
However, the 18-year-old couldn’t handle the limelight that came too soon. His career spiraled downward immediately after, drifting through dozens of unknown teams in lower leagues.
4. Carlos Alberto
-
Match: FC Porto vs AS Monaco (Champions League Final, 2004).
Brazilian football always produces geniuses, and in 2004, Carlos Alberto was seen as the “next Ronaldinho”. Under the guidance of Jose Mourinho, this 19-year-old opened the scoring in the Champions League final, paving the way for Porto’s resounding 3-0 victory.
People expect him to win the Ballon d’Or in the future. But reality wrote a cruel script. After Mourinho left, Carlos Alberto drowned in star syndrome and indiscipline. He was quickly pushed out of elite European football, drifted back to his homeland Brazil, and ended his career to the immense regret of football fans.
3. Oleg Salenko
-
Match: Russia vs Cameroon (World Cup Group Stage, 1994).
If one had to find the most bizarre statistical anomaly in football history, it would definitely be Russian striker Oleg Salenko. In a dead-rubber match against Cameroon at the 1994 World Cup, Salenko set an unprecedented record by scoring a staggering 5 goals in just 90 minutes.
Combined with a penalty scoring earlier against Sweden, he reached 6 goals to share the Golden Boot with Hristo Stoichkov. But the craziest part is: those 6 goals at the 1994 World Cup were the only goals he ever scored for the Russian national team in his entire career.
His international legacy was literally built and finished within a single tournament, heavily carried by one freakish 90-minute masterclass.
2. Éder
-
Match: Portugal vs France (Euro Final, 2016).
Before the Euro 2016 final, Éder was considered the “joke” of the Portuguese national team. He was a clumsy striker, often making mistakes and constantly being booed by his own fans every time he touched the ball. When Cristiano Ronaldo had to leave the field early due to injury, millions of Portuguese shed tears of despair.
However, the moment manager Fernando Santos brought Éder on changed European football history. In the 109th minute of extra time, he unleashed a cannonball from outside the box, beating Hugo Lloris and bringing Portugal their first-ever major trophy.
From an outcast, he became a “demigod”, in a single night. However, Éder’s magic also vanished permanently after that shot, and he never grew into a world-class striker.
1. Federico Macheda
-
Match: Manchester United vs Aston Villa (Premier League, 2009).
No one in this world can define the phrase “One-Match Wonder”, as perfectly, completely, and epically as Federico Macheda.
At that time, Manchester United was in an injury crisis and on the verge of losing the Premier League title. In a deadlocked game against Aston Villa, Sir Alex Ferguson decided to take a gamble by throwing on an entirely unknown 17-year-old academy kid.
In the 93rd minute, with the score tied at 2-2, Macheda received the ball in the box, executed a brilliant turn to lose his defender, and curled a beautiful strike into the far corner. Old Trafford exploded. That goal saved the Red Devils’ season and was the direct turning point that secured the championship trophy that year.
The world bowed to Macheda’s outstanding talent. But tragically, that fateful touch was also his final piece of elite magic. Throughout the rest of his career, Macheda wandered through various unknown clubs in England, Italy, and Turkey. He never found the miracle of that magical afternoon at the Theatre of Dreams.
