In the ruthless world of the Premier League, “40 points” has long been considered the holy grail of survival. But history proves that hitting this mythical mark doesn’t always guarantee safety.
Managers and pundits often preach the same gospel: reach 40 points, and you are safe from the drop. However, English football history is littered with teams that fought tirelessly, reached or even surpassed the 40-point threshold, yet still suffered the heartbreak of relegation.
Because the Premier League previously featured 42-game seasons (with 22 teams) before reducing to the current 38-game format, the fairest metric to measure exactly how “unlucky” a relegated team was is Points Per Game (PPG).
Here is the countdown of the 8 highest-scoring relegated teams in Premier League history.
8. Blackpool (2010/11)
- Total Points: 39 points (38 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.026
Under the guidance of Ian Holloway, newly-promoted Blackpool played a brand of fearless attacking football that won the hearts of neutrals everywhere. They refused to park the bus against anyone.
On a dramatic final day, Blackpool even took a shock 2-1 lead against Manchester United at Old Trafford. However, the Red Devils eventually showcased their pedigree, mounting a comeback to win 4-2 and instantly shattering Blackpool’s survival dreams despite being agonizingly close to the 40-point mark.
7. Birmingham City (2010/11)
- Total Points: 39 points (38 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.026
Sharing the exact same points tally and fate as Blackpool that year were Birmingham City, but their narrative was arguably even more tragic.
In February 2011, Birmingham shocked the country by defeating Arsenal to lift the Carling Cup. However, that glorious cup run seemingly drained their domestic energy. On the final day of the season, a 93rd-minute goal from Tottenham’s Roman Pavlyuchenko condemned the recently crowned League Cup winners to the Championship.
6. West Ham United (2025/26)
- Total Points: 39 points (38 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.026
A massive shock that just unfolded before our eyes.
Despite boasting an incredibly expensive squad, the Hammers suffered a catastrophic collapse during the business end of the season.
Even after grinding their way to 39 points – a tally that is usually more than enough to secure safety in the modern era, West Ham were sent crashing down to the Championship. This disaster cements their legacy as one of the unluckiest clubs in England, making them the only team to appear on this heartbreaking list twice.
5. Bolton Wanderers (1997/98)
- Total Points: 40 points (38 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.053
Bolton stands as the ultimate proof that hitting the mythical 40-point mark is never a guarantee of safety.
Managed by Colin Todd, Bolton went into the final day needing a miracle. They lost 2-0 to Chelsea, while their direct relegation rivals, Everton, managed a nervy 1-1 draw against Coventry City.
Tied on exactly 40 points, Bolton were relegated from the top flight simply because of goal difference (-21 compared to Everton’s -16).
4. Sunderland (1996/97)
- Total Points: 40 points (38 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.053
Another victim of the 40-point curse.
Peter Reid’s Sunderland fought tooth and nail, proudly reaching the fabled 40-point milestone. They went into the final matchday with their fate in their own hands.
However, the Premier League always delivers late drama.
Sunderland suffered a 1-0 defeat to Wimbledon, while relegation rivals Coventry City pulled off a miracle 2-1 away victory at Tottenham. That final twist of the knife dropped the Black Cats into 18th place, leaving fans in utter disbelief.
3. Crystal Palace (1994/95)
- Total Points: 45 points (42 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.071
The South London club became the direct victim of a massive structural change to the league.
Ahead of the 1995/96 season, the FA decided to reduce the Premier League from 22 teams to 20. This meant that four teams, rather than the usual three, would face the drop.
Despite a highly respectable campaign where they accumulated 45 points, Palace finished 19th and were sacrificed for the sake of the league’s transition.
2. West Ham United (2002/03)
- Total Points: 42 points (38 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.105
Widely regarded by pundits as the “greatest relegated squad in history”.
West Ham’s 2002/03 roster was packed with a golden generation of talent, featuring Michael Carrick, Jermain Defoe, Joe Cole, and the legendary Paolo Di Canio. They set an unwanted record that still stands today: the most points ever accumulated by a relegated team in a 38-game season (42 points).
Their valiant 2-2 draw against Birmingham on the final day meant nothing, as Bolton beat Middlesbrough to secure top-flight survival.
1. Crystal Palace (1992/93)
- Total Points: 49 points (42 games)
- Points Per Game (PPG): 1.167
The undisputed kings of relegation heartbreak.
During the inaugural Premier League season, Crystal Palace displayed form that would easily secure a comfortable mid-table finish today. They amassed a staggering 49 points – a colossal achievement for a team battling the drop.
Yet, in a season of pure madness, 49 points were only enough to tie with Oldham Athletic. Losing out on goal difference (-15 to -11), Crystal Palace officially became the highest-scoring relegated team (by PPG) in the history of English football.
You have just read the article “The 40-Point Myth: 8 Teams Relegated with the Most Points in Premier League History”. Follow 52Hz Football for more captivating stories about football, geography and culture.
READ MORE:
- 8 Players with Most Assists in a Premier League Season: Bruno Fernandes Breaks Record
- All Players Who Played for Both Arsenal and Crystal Palace
- All Players Who Played for Both Man United and Brighton
- 5 Players Who Played for Both PSG and Arsenal, ft. Arteta
