The list of players who played for both Manchester United and AS Roma is a short one, connecting Old Trafford and the Stadio Olimpico across different generations.
Some moved directly between the clubs; others reached Rome after spells elsewhere. Their stories include Premier League title winners, European champions and a striker whose Roma career lasted just one season.
All statistics cover senior competitive matches in all competitions, including loan appearances.
Last updated: 1 November 2026.
1. Gabriel Heinze
- Manchester United: 2004–2007 (Apps: 83 | Goals: 4)
- AS Roma: 2011–2012 (Apps: 32 | Goals: 0)
Gabriel Heinze was the first of these five to represent United, joining from Paris Saint-Germain in 2004. The Argentine’s forceful tackling, aerial aggression and ability to play at left-back or centre-back made him a distinctive member of Sir Alex Ferguson’s defence. He helped United win the 2006/07 Premier League before leaving for Real Madrid that summer.
He reached Roma in 2011 after spells in Madrid and at Marseille. Under Luis Enrique, he supplied experience to a squad also featuring Francesco Totti, Daniele De Rossi and Miralem Pjanić. Seven years after his United arrival, Heinze was bringing the later stages of his European career into a new Italian project.
His Roma career lasted just one season, but 32 competitive appearances gave it more substance than a brief stopover. The Giallorossi finished seventh in Serie A, and Heinze returned to Newell’s Old Boys in 2012. His route between Old Trafford and the Olimpico covered two other major European clubs before his arrival in Italy.

2. Chris Smalling
- Manchester United: 2010–2020 (Apps: 323 | Goals: 18)
- AS Roma: 2019–2024 (Apps: 155 | Goals: 10)
Chris Smalling built the longest-lasting Roma career of the five. United signed him from Fulham in 2010, and he became part of the defence that won two Premier League titles during Sir Alex Ferguson’s final years. His time at Old Trafford also brought FA Cup and Europa League success.
With regular starts becoming harder to secure, Smalling joined Roma on loan in 2019. The move became permanent in October 2020, so his United contract dates extend beyond his last season playing for the club. In Italy, he established himself as an important central defender under Paulo Fonseca and later José Mourinho.

His defining Roma night came in the 2022 Conference League final against Feyenoord. UEFA named Smalling Player of the Match after he helped protect a 1–0 lead. His commanding defensive display secured a memorable place in the club’s European history.
By the time he left for Al-Fayha in September 2024, he had made 155 Roma appearances. He served both clubs for substantial periods and won European silverware with each.
3. Henrikh Mkhitaryan
- Manchester United: 2016–2018 (Apps: 63 | Goals: 13)
- AS Roma: 2019–2022 (Apps: 117 | Goals: 29*)
Henrikh Mkhitaryan’s United career is best remembered for his contribution to their 2016/17 Europa League triumph. Signed from Borussia Dortmund in 2016, the Armenian attacker scored six goals in the competition, including the finish that completed the 2–0 final win over Ajax. His famous scorpion kick against Sunderland provided another lasting Old Trafford memory.
He stayed for 18 months before joining Arsenal in January 2018 in the deal that brought Alexis Sánchez to United. Roma eventually signed him on loan from Arsenal in 2019 and later secured him permanently. His path between Manchester and Rome therefore included an important stop in north London.

In the Italian capital, Mkhitaryan combined creativity with intelligent movement between the lines. He played under Paulo Fonseca before reuniting with Mourinho, offering the versatility to connect midfield and attack from several positions. His three seasons ended with Roma’s 2022 Conference League success, before he moved to Inter. For both United and Roma, European football provides the clearest link between his talent and his most significant achievements.
4. Nemanja Matić
- Manchester United: 2017–2022 (Apps: 189 | Goals: 4)
- AS Roma: 2022–2023 (Apps: 50 | Goals: 2)
Nemanja Matić followed Mourinho from Chelsea to Manchester United in 2017, arriving as an experienced holding midfielder. His main responsibilities were to protect the defence, offer a reliable passing option and help control the tempo. Across five seasons, his contribution usually depended on positioning and composure rather than a high goalscoring return.
One spectacular exception came against Crystal Palace in March 2018. His stoppage-time volley completed United’s recovery from two goals down to win 3–2, providing the defining attacking highlight of his Old Trafford career.

Roma signed Matić on a free transfer in June 2022, creating a third club reunion with Mourinho. He joined a side fresh from winning the Conference League and helped it reach the following season’s Europa League final. Roma drew 1–1 with Sevilla in Budapest before losing on penalties.
His Italian stay lasted one season, but 50 appearances demonstrate how regularly he was used. Matić moved to Rennes in August 2023, leaving a compact Roma chapter built around the same midfield discipline that had defined his United years.
5. Romelu Lukaku
- Manchester United: 2017–2019 (Apps: 96 | Goals: 42)
- AS Roma: 2023–2024 (loan) (Apps: 47 | Goals: 21)
Romelu Lukaku joined United from Everton in 2017 and scored 42 times in 96 competitive appearances. His first season produced strong numbers, although his second became more difficult as the club changed managers from Mourinho to Ole Gunnar Solskjær. He left for Inter in 2019, beginning an Italian chapter that would eventually lead to Roma.
His Roma move arrived in August 2023 through a season-long loan from Chelsea, with another Mourinho reunion forming part of the appeal. It was a third club at which the two had worked together, after Chelsea and United. The deal also partnered Lukaku with Paulo Dybala, giving Roma a pair of internationally established forwards.
Lukaku finished the campaign with 21 goals in 47 appearances, contributing domestically and in Europe. Daniele De Rossi replaced Mourinho during the season, but Lukaku remained an important attacking option for a side that reached the Europa League semi-finals.
The loan did not become a permanent transfer, leaving his spell at just one year. Even so, he has the highest Roma goals-per-appearance ratio among the five players on this list.
Davide Petrucci: An Academy Connection
Davide Petrucci moved from Roma’s youth setup to Manchester United in 2008. The Italian midfielder was regarded as a promising recruit, but never made a competitive first-team appearance for United.
His academy story belongs alongside this shared history, separately from the five senior careers above.
The José Mourinho Connection
Four of the five – Smalling, Mkhitaryan, Matić and Lukaku – played under José Mourinho at both clubs.
Smalling and Mkhitaryan were already in Rome when he arrived; Matić and Lukaku subsequently reunited with him there. That shared coaching history gives the Manchester United and AS Roma connection a distinctive character.

You have just read the article “5 Players Who Played for Both Manchester United and AS Roma”. Follow 52HzFootball for more captivating stories about football, geography and culture.

